There is an uncomfortable tension in inclusive leadership right now. Leaders may genuinely care about creating workplaces where different people can contribute, be heard and have equitable opportunities.
At the same time, some are increasingly worried about saying ‘the wrong thing’, choosing the wrong language or making a mistake. But what happens when caution becomes paralysis or silence?
This was one of the most thought-provoking parts of my recent conversation with Rob Neil OBE, founder of KA Harrow, recorded during Black History Month in the UK. Rob has spent decades working around race equity, inclusion and culture change, and his perspective was clear- inclusion is not a linear journey, and doing nothing is not a neutral position.
Progress is a constant action
One of Rob’s first points was that organisations cannot assume that because they have had a successful inclusion initiative, that every situation will be handled well next time. The context changes, people change, leadership changes, and the wider geopolitical conditions influence the conversation.
That matters because inclusion can easily become something organisations believe they have ‘done’ with a defined strategy, a full-attendance workshop, or published statement. Yet the real test comes later, when budgets tighten, priorities compete or somebody challenges the approach.
Rob’s invitation to leaders is to keep asking- what are we learning, whose voice is missing from the conversation, whose experience do we not understand fully, and what could create a more equitable outcome next time?
Want to lead more effectively across difference?
Explore practical strategies for strengthening your Cultural Intelligence, communication and leadership impact.
Hearing is not the same as listening
Rob made an important distinction between listening and hearing. Organisations may create consultation processes, invite views and ask people to speak, yet still make decisions that show those perspectives have not been fully included or heard, and do not influence the final outcome.
For leaders, this is where Cultural Intelligence comes in, something both Rob and I believe can support the opening up of the conversation. Who feels able to speak up and contribute? Whose voice is dominant and who remains silent? Who is expected to adapt?
The leadership question here is, what do you understand from asking for diverse perspectives, and what changes because you have heard it?
Fear can become a leadership problem
Rob spoke candidly about professionals he meets who are fearful about making a misstep on inclusion to the point of silence or paralysis. In some cases, they worry that taking a position on inclusion could damage their career or even threaten their job.
But leadership still involves choice- if fear continually narrows who we invite in, what we challenge or the inequities we address, self-protection starts shaping the outcome.
This is where Rob’s balance of support and challenge matters. Too much support can leave people comfortable and unchanged. Too much challenge can make them defensive and closed. Learning sits in the space where people feel sufficiently supported to stay in the conversation, but challenged enough to think and act differently.
What happens when fear of ‘getting it wrong’ stops action and creates silence?
Hear my full conversation with Rob Neil OBE on moving from intention to meaningful action.
Start with ‘why’ before rushing to ‘what’
Rob also shared a simple but powerful framework: understand, lead and deliver. The order matters.
He described organisations approaching him after the murder of George Floyd asking for an anti-racist statement. His first question was why they wanted one. If the underlying purpose is unclear, the visible action is fragile, and the first difficult challenge, budget cut or leadership change can blow away the progress on inclusion.
Understanding the ‘why’ behind the drive to change creates a stronger foundation, when inclusion becomes a personal, team and organisational commitment- what are you prepared to do differently? What systems, behaviours and decisions need to change?
Good intentions can still fail in delivery
One example from Rob’s work brought this to life- a bank was designing a scheme to encourage staff to refer talented people from their families and communities to their recruitment scheme. The intention was positive, but the proposed name carried a deeply negative cultural connotation.
The problem was the failure to test how the positioning and name would land with people who understood the issue from their lived experience. Rob described these people as the ‘intrinsic owners’ of the issue.
His advice, before introducing something new, involve people who understand how it is likely to be received and experienced. Ask with curiosity and humility questions such as, how does this land? What are we missing? How could we make it better?
Inclusion becomes real through action
As we came to the end of our conversation, Rob brought the discussion back to a very practical question- what can you personally do to help create a more equitable outcome?
That question does not pretend one leader can solve every problem alone, but it also does not allow the scale of the issue to become a reason for passivity.
Black History Month in the UK is in October, and this can create a useful moment to focus attention, learn and open conversations, but the work is year-round. Inclusion is built through the decisions made, the voices that are genuinely listened to, the questions you can stay curious about and what you choose to do next.
Questions to reflect on
Where might fear of ‘getting it wrong’ be holding back your team?
Whose voice is not being heard in your team?
Before your next inclusion initiative, how clear are you on the drive for change?





