Confidence is often misunderstood. In my work with experienced leaders, I see that even the most senior leaders can have their low-confidence moments.
Someone can have twenty-five years’ experience, a strong track record and the respect of colleagues, then a shift of context, whether positive or negative, such as a promotion, restructure, redundancy risk or move to a new organisation or country, can suddenly make them question themselves.
Their capability, experience and past achievements have not diminished, but the context has changed.
I was reminded of this recently at the Women’s Leadership Breakfast I hosted in Paris, where 8 of us gathered from different sectors to come together to talk honestly about confidence, what strengthens it, what unsettles it and how we find our way back when it shifts.
Although the details of the conversation itself are confidential, there were four different sources of confidence which emerged: self, others, context and state.
1. Self-confidence changes as leadership expands
Earlier in our careers, confidence can come from visible achievement and career advancement. You develop expertise, know the details, deliver reliably, receive positive feedback and can point clearly to what you have created.
As we become more senior, that source becomes less reliable, as your remit becomes broader, you become the leader of a team, where your people are the experts.
The leadership shift is from ‘I am confident because I know’ towards ‘I trust myself even when I do not yet know’.
I regularly coach leaders who have already been promoted and objectively have the organisation’s endorsement that they are ready, yet internally they still feel exposed and lacking. The title has changed faster than their sense of leadership identity.
Self-confidence at this level is less about proving yourself repeatedly and more about trusting your judgement, your ability to learn and your capacity to find a way through, even when you don’t have the answers.
Facing questions about confidence?
Become a Global Leader, the book, explores Confidence as one of the key pillars.
2. The flow of confidence to and from others
One of the ideas from the Paris leadership conversation was the role and interplay of other people in our confidence.
Consider for yourself- who amplifies your confidence? Who energises you? Who backs you in an important room? Who reminds you of your strengths when you have temporarily lost sight of them?
But there is another side to this if you lead others: whose confidence are you helping to build? Are you creating enough space for somebody else to lead the discussion, present to senior stakeholders, test an idea or take visible ownership?
Leadership is not only managing your own confidence, but you also shape the conditions in which other people develop theirs.
3. When the context changes, confidence can shift too
A new team, organisation, role or country can make an experienced professional question themselves, because the ‘old rules’ of what has worked previously in their leadership style may no longer apply in quite the same way.
Success may be defined differently, relationships and trust need to be built, and you may be learning new cultural or organisational norms, while people are already looking to you for answers.
One idea from the women at the breakfast captured an alternative to forcing confidence- spaciousness.
Instead of pushing harder, controlling every variable or ‘putting on your armour’, confidence can mean allowing yourself not to know, to experiment, to make mistakes and still trust that you remain the same capable leader.
This is often about allowing imperfection, and expanding your capacity to lead without certainty.
What happens to confidence when the context around you changes?
In this podcast episode, I explore four different sources of confidence.
4. Know how to shift your state
The final part of the confidence conversation for today is what happens after a setback.
Life happens and I have supported many professionals through their tough moments- when they do not get the promotion, when they receive difficult feedback they were not expecting, when a project fails, when their role disappears, or when something that mattered to them does not work out.
Confidence is knowing what you need to help move you forward, to help you recover and get back on track.
For some people, the most useful response is to zoom out- ask whether this will matter in six or twelve months’ time, put the situation into perspective and reconnect with the bigger picture of what opportunities might lie on the other side of this bump in the road.
For others, it is almost the opposite, zoom in- feel the disappointment properly, process it over a period of time, before letting go of the feelings to move forward.
In my experience, other ways to make that shift are about a physical context switch, through walking, exercise, changing the environment of where you are working, talking to a trusted thinking partner or writing things down in a journal.
You may have a feeling of what works for you, and if you don’t yet, experiment with a few ideas here. The important thing is to have some approaches and methods to try, if you meet this experience.
Has a setback, challenge or restructure knocked your confidence?
Coaching can help you create clarity and move forward when you’re questioning yourself.
Questions to reflect on
Where is your confidence coming from most right now: self, others, context or state?
Where are you trying to force confidence through control, rather than allowing space to get it wrong?
What helps you get back on track after a setback?





